FashionVOTE by He...Who Wore it Better?

Two weeks in a row now we are back with the FashionVOTE by He, big fan of these type of posts. This weeks addition of "FashionVOTE by He" is Rompers and Wedges VS. a Dress and Wedges, let the dueling begin. Who Wore it Better? But first, let's break down what we are looking at...

Girl 1: Romper. This might be her younger sisters romper as her ass was nearly falling out the bottom. Smile. Her hair was all over the place, making He think its very possible, she was walking home from a "long night out." She has black wedges on that appear to be about 3" or so, but they don't even look like they mesh well with the outfit. Oddly enough she has a black bag that might or might not be the same one as Girl 2.
Girl 2: Dress instead of a romper, hmm the decision is yours. What catches He's eye the most are the wedges. These are real woman wedges, not that small as sh*t. Go Big or Go Home kind of wedges. It gets He's vote for those alone.
-He

Time for the ArmHE to Vote:
Vote I Agree: Girl 1
Vote I Disagree: Girl 2